or Login to submit your own content and comments.
THE M.B.A. ….. THE DEVIL'S WORK…….
FOR PEOPLE STARTING UP IN BUSINESS!

By Robert Craven


The MBA can destroy your ability to set up and run your own business. Smart-assed, newly qualified, MBA graduates think that their piece of paper qualifies them to be a freelance consultant…. or to run their own business. Absolute nonsense.


Running a business is about action, it is not about theory - what is great in the classroom (because it is intellectually attractive or academically rigorous) is probably irrelevant in the real world.

I confess that business planning is a great way to make your mistakes on paper; however, you learn even more in the marketplace - it is brutally honest and gives you real feedback. You will be successful if you provide something that people want…. in a way that they want it. The best (and fastest) way to learn is by spending your own money and by paying for your own mistakes. I have been rich and I have been poor and I know which one I prefer!!

There is one basic question you need to ask yourself about your new business - why should people bother to buy your product? And why should they bother to buy from you, especially when there are so many other people selling similar products at similar prices? So, what will make you different?

In general, do not compete on price - the bigger organisations with bigger budgets and buying power will always beat the smaller player on price. You must compete on everything but the price. Be faster, smarter, slower, nicer, cleverer, more local…… but, be different somehow.

So, what do you need to consider to set up on your own?

The Market - Really, how good is your idea? Test it on friends and strangers. What problem are you solving? Who will buy your product? Why? Who are your competitors? How will you be different/better/smarter? How will you make the first/tenth/hundredth sale? You will make no sales if it is either, a lousy product, or, because of your lousy marketing. Throw away Kotler and listen to potential customers.

Objectives - What is the business trying to achieve? If you don't know where you are going then any road will do. What is your motivation? What is your definition of success?

Resources - What do you own and what can you use to make the business idea come to fruition (physical, human, intellectual and financial resources)? What will you need in a year's time?

Financials - What do the projected cash-flow and profit and loss forecasts look like? How are prices set? What is the cost structure? The key issues are economic viability, price and profit.

Ability - Have you got what it takes? How relevant is your knowledge, attitude, circumstances, experience and character?


AND SOME DO'S AND DON'TS…..

  • Brand it; Brand YOURELF - you cannot not communicate your brand. Everything about your business communicates something. So, what is it that you want to be communicating?

  • Spend a day with weird people - sharpen your thinking by spending some time with people who come at things from a different angle. The best ideas will come from the strangest of places.

  • Create marketing space - Separate yourself from the competition. Make yourself different.

  • Remove your self-limiting beliefs - what limits have you set for yourself sub-consciously? If you believe that you cannot swim, then you will not be able to swim. How do you limit yourself?

  • Feel the fear and do it anyway - fear is a perfectly natural emotion. If you aren't sailing close to the wind then you are probably not taking enough risks. Acknowledge the fear and make a calculated decision. Use the adrenaline and energy that the fear creates to work for you rather than against you.

  • Work on, not in your business - when Ray Krock started McDonald''s, he never intended to work in the business cooking beefburgers; he always intended to work on the business, creating the architecture, the empire.

  • Less is more - simplify everything

  • Cut the excuses - just do it

  • Ask stupid questions

  • Don't shy away from passion

  • Keep it simple, stupid!


  • TO RECAP….

    You need:
  • Vision - the ability to see into the future, to imagine how things could be

  • Passion - a sheer belief and conviction in one's ideas and actions

  • Determination - the willingness to persevere, often against the odds to create something new where there was nothing
  • Communication and delegation skills - the ability to muster the skills and efforts of other people to help to create and deliver a dream - to take something from the imagination and turn it into an actual product or service that people will buy
  • .







    Robert Craven runs The Directors' Centre, the consultancy for growing businesses. Robert is a keynote speaker, consultant and author of the business best-sellers, 'Kick-Start Your Business' and 'Customer Is King' (Foreword by Sir Richard Branson). The FT describes him as 'the entrepreneurship guru' and The Independent describes his books as 'truly inspirational'. Robert also runs the ecademy club, .Kick-Start Your Business'.

    Robert can be contacted on 01225 851044 or rc@thedc.co.uk or visit www.thedc.co.uk .




    or Login to submit your own content and comments.
    view this person's profile

    THE MBA... THE DEVIL'S WORK - oh no!

    Likes (0) by Amber Burton on 21-Jul-03 1:21pm
    Robert.

    I am amazed.

    I have been running a variety of successful IT and marketing businessess, at Director level, for more than 15 years. Just this year I took the plunge and enrolled on a 4 year MBA. Finishing my first year, I find myself challenged, motivated, more street-wise and more able to spot bulls***t when I see it, than ever before.

    I take your point completely that an MBA in no way replaces hands-on business management. I've got enough experience to know that nothing beats doing it yourself, making your own mistakes, learning the ropes.

    But that doesn't mean that an MBA is redundant - quite the opposite. For me, it has provided an objective sounding board for all the principles I hold dear and all the experience I have amassed. Indeed, without a certain level of prior business knowledge, an MBA becomes extremely difficult to achieve.

    So I take exception to your assertion that "smart-assed, newly qualified, MBA graduates think that their piece of paper qualifies them to be a freelance consultant…. or to run their own business." 15 years of doing it the hard way makes me smart-assed - and damn proud of my MBA student status.

    Amber.
    view this person's profile

    THE MBA... THE DEVIL'S WORK - oh no!

    Likes (0) by Sue (Contracts) McGaughran on 21-Jul-03 4:32pm
    Sue McGaughran
    CEO
    www.limeone.com
    0870 240 4325

    I think an awful lot of cr**p is spoken about MBA qualifications generally. They certanly do provide in depth business study which coupled with professional and business experience provide useful tools. Having taught on MBA programmes for some time now, I see many more mature people coming into the classes with lengthy CVS. For those managers who have developed their skills through practical application rather than study, this is a golden opportunity to structure their thinking in a different measurable way, for most it is like finding the missing piece of the jigsaw.

    MBA study is not the panacea of all ills sure, but neither is it a waste of time for those like Amber and many others who decide on a structured study path for self development.

    Few MBA schools allow fresh newly qualified first degree holders onto the MBA course these days, so a lot of the posting in the originating blog is not current with today's admission profile.

    Good on Amber for embarking on such a challenge we will continue to explode the myth that business learnt at the sharp end is the only way to hone skills. You need balance to survive.
    view this person's profile

    THE MBA... THE DEVIL'S WORK - oh no!

    Likes (0) by Paul Goldsmith on 22-Jul-03 8:29am
    I have a feeling that the author of the above article has had some bad experiences with MBAs, and I can understand that happening. I work in Public Relations and have just finished an MBA at CASS Business School in London. People have told me stories about MBAs in PR, saying that they just didin't "get it" and would call journalists spouting theories and lecture anyone in sight. Luckily, my business school told us never to do that unless you are absolutely sure you are in the right company.

    Ultimately the author above speaks sense about marketing and branding and running a business, yet all he is actually doing is repeating what I learned in the past year. So, maybe he's been working with MBAs who came out in 1996 spouting Kotler, but that doesn't mean our education hasn't moved on.

    Comment removed
    view this person's profile

    THE MBA... THE DEVIL'S WORK - oh no!

    Likes (0) by Paul Goldsmith on 23-Jul-03 9:06am
    Ron

    But that's my point, MBAs in the 1960s may have been irrelevant, MBAs in the 1990s may have been irrelevant. But I've just done my MBA and we have been taught all that Robert said- and for someone like me who left IT aiming for a career change it has been brilliant.

    Robert may have met people who spout Kotler at him but I'd like to know when they did their MBAs. I'd also like to tell them to stop letting us MBAs down as well smile

    Paul
    view this person's profile

    THE MBA... THE DEVIL'S WORK.....FOR PEOPLE STARTING IN BUSINESS!

    Likes (0) by Kaleem Aziz on 7-Oct-03 11:22pm
    Education has always been like that ... it is a team play of the student and the teacher. If the teacher doesn't inspire (the student to check with reality) or if the student doesn't listen, we'll always have much of the above being written against the actions of MBA graduates.

    MBA graduates empowered with a role and powerful position think they are powerful with or without the people they help. But that is short lived, and they learn quickly through their mistakes where their place is.

    If the world is an ocean, a business is a ship. If a MBA graduate thinks he is controlling the ocean and not the ship -- and thinks he can ask the ocean to steer right instead of him having to contribute to steering the ship; reality has ways to teach "what works".

    A good joke to drive this point would be:
    This is the transcript of the actual radio conversation of a US Naval ship with the Canadian authorities off the coast of Newfoundland in Oct 1995.

    Radio conversation released by chief of naval operations 10/10/95.

    Canadians: Please divert your course 15 degrees to the south to avoid a collision.

    Americans: Recommend you divert your course 15 degrees to the north.

    Canadians: Negative. You will have to divert your course 15 degrees to the south to avoid a collision.

    Americans: This is the captain of a US navy ship. I say again, divert your course.

    Canadians: No. I say again, divert your course.

    Americans: This is the aircraft carrier USS Lincoln. The second biggest ship in the United States Atlantic fleet. We are accompanied by three destroyers, three cruisers and numerous support vessels. I demand that you change your course 15 degrees north, that's one five degrees north, or counter measures will be undertaken to ensure the safety of this ship.

    Canadians: We are a lighthouse. Your call.


    PS: I hear in other circles that my university students refused to network with other university students because they thought it would hurt their reputation -- another sign of wrong lessons in practice, whereas we are taught to put "people first", not "power first".

    Thanks.
    Kaleem.
    "Businesses are tools of the humans, by the humans, for the humans." -- my Theory of Everything ('What is a tool?' at http://aziz_kaleem.tripod.com/WS/index.blog?from=20030531)
    view this person's profile

    THE MBA... THE DEVIL'S WORK.....FOR PEOPLE STARTING IN BUSINESS!

    Likes (0) by Kaleem Aziz on 8-Oct-03 10:16pm
    Hope you'll find the FedEx advertisement funny:
    http://www.fedex.com/us/about/advertising/tvads/mbaqt.html

    Thanks.
    Kaleem.
    "Businesses are tools of the humans, by the humans, for the humans." -- my Theory of Everything ('What is a tool?' at http://aziz_kaleem.tripod.com/WS/index.blog?from=20030531)